With the launch of the Kindle DX there was lots of commentary about the value of the DX as an academic eReader. After all, text books are expensive and what better device might there be than an eReader with a large display?
Unfortunately, ReadWriteWeb reports that “Forrester warns that universities will be slow to adopt the technology. The schools that Forrester talked to had no plans to encourage students to use the Kindle and the current pilot project only involves a small number of students (50 at Pace, for example).”
Really?
To me, there are several reasons that eReaders are a natural point of adoption in schools:
* Cost. It’s not just the cost of the printed books. It’s all the cost that goes into convincing people to make an investment in the printed books. Offering a subscription model for books is a natural here.
* With the ability to update electronic materials faster than their printed cousins, the eReader would seem to be an obvious choice.
* Weight. The eReaders are a lot lighter than printed titles.
* Once interactivity makes its way into eReaders there’s going to be lots of opportunity here. What do I mean? Touch is an obvious opportunity. Annotation is another. In fact, I wouldn’t be surprised to see a “Tablet” eReader in the future.
* Price. eReaders offer a better price point than their general purpose computing counterparts. It only makes sense. Give me a general purpose computing device and I’ll show you a device that’s twice as expensive to operate.
* Sealed, focus devices are easier to control and therefore easier to code for. No 3G needed. Content is all available behind a school firewall.
* eReaders have a book model that fits schools much better. No need for general purpose computing devices. Classrooms already are all about books. No need to retrain teachers.
One challenge to a special device for reading is, “What does the electronic version do better than paper?” It’s while in use that is special issue. Notes are one possibility, then syncing those to students’ portals & maybe sharing joint notes. Paper is manual and slower. There are other possibilities too.
Another challenge is how can schools replace the value of used book resale? Bookstores and students make money off of this. Also, rapid download can be a value for the student as compared with waiting in line at a bookstore or ordering online, but only once per quarter or semester. I think the daily benefits rank higher than the occassional benefit.
Will K-12 schools adopt eReaders? http://tinyurl.com/qvt6pn
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Melia, as far as I understand its only for grad students. all the articles mention only grad students. you could check out the uw cs department page describing the pilot program and get in touch with the Prof in charge to confirm/check if there’s a way to get it as an undergraduate.
This comment was originally posted on Kindle 2 Review – Kindle DX Review, Books
You mentioned that the Foster Business School will be participating in the Kindle DX Review program as well…but how are they allocating them Kindles to the students? Are the business undergraduates involved?
This comment was originally posted on Kindle 2 Review – Kindle DX Review, Books
You mentioned that the Foster Business School will be participating in the Kindle DX Review program as well…but how are they allocating them Kindles to the students? Are the business undergraduates involved?
This comment was originally posted on Amazon Kindle, Books, Kindle 2.0 – Amazon Kindle Review
Melia, as far as I understand its only for grad students. all the articles mention only grad students. you could check out the uw cs department page describing the pilot program and get in touch with the Prof in charge to confirm/check if there’s a way to get it as an undergraduate.
This comment was originally posted on Amazon Kindle, Books, Kindle 2.0 – Amazon Kindle Review